Difference between revisions of "User:AAE/Chris's TRUE and HONEST Gender"
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
==Chris's attraction to women, and how it differs from that of a straight man== | ==Chris's attraction to women, and how it differs from that of a straight man== | ||
==The curse of genetics== | ==The curse of genetics: Things Chris can't help== | ||
Passing isn't all about hormones and surgery – for many, you have to win the genetic lottery to begin with. For every Blaire White or Samantha Lux gaining notoriety for being a passing trans woman, you have Christine, cursed with a barrel chest and receding hairline. None of that is a reflection on Chris's status as a trans woman, though. It's no fault of her own, either. | Passing isn't all about hormones and surgery – for many, you have to win the genetic lottery to begin with. Bone structure can't be changed, with a few exceptions like the bones of the face. Even then, surgery is expensive. There is no surgery to remove height (minus cutting off the legs) or narrow the shoulders. While HRT can ''prevent'' hair loss, it generally can't ''reverse'' it. Even Rogaine isn't perfect, and most wigs within Chris's budget will look obviously synthetic. | ||
For every Blaire White or Samantha Lux gaining notoriety for being a passing trans woman, you have Christine, cursed with a barrel chest and receding hairline. None of that is a reflection on Chris's status as a trans woman, though. It's no fault of her own, either. | |||
==Voice== | ==Voice== | ||
Revision as of 21:27, 4 February 2021
 | This essay reflects the opinion of its author and/or a minority viewpoint and does not meet CWCki quality standards of encyclopedic value. Reader discretion is advised. |
What is Chris's TRUE and HONEST gender identity? That is the question.
This topic has sparked fervent debate among the Christorian community. Kiwi Farms members overwhelmingly call Chris "he," and so does the CWCki main space. Geno Samuel called her "he" up until Chris started using she/her pronouns, making the change rather seamlessly I might add. The issue is even divided among trans folks covering Chris: Natalie Wynn (Contrapoints) used she/her, while Rose of Dawn used he/him.
It is my personal belief that Chris is a genuine trans woman, a "troon" if you prefer. She just has some obstacles that not all trans women have to face.
But isn't it just the autism doing the talking?
Not exactly. Most studies on the matter have found a correlation between autism and being trans, but none have actually gone beyond educated guesses when it comes to the cause.
Autistic trans folks do exist. Look up Ella Grant. She's feminine as ever as well.
But what about the extreme male brain?
It's time to delve into the world of neuroscience.
While some psychs still perpetuate the outdated "extreme male brain" theory of autism, modern brain research has found that autistic brains are actually quite androgynous. [1] While some areas of the brain are masculinized in autistics, others are feminized, such as the parts related to sensory and motor processing. If anything, autistic folks have extreme non-binary brains!
Furthermore, the differences between male and female brains are not absolute, even in cis folks: there is an 89.6% overlap between male and female brains, compared to a 31.7 overlap in terms of height. Brain sex is bimodal, not binary.[2]
In fact, for our purposes, it's pretty irrelevant. Research has found that the main difference between trans women and men pre-HRT is in the putamen.[3] This tells us that the putamen is the brain's gender center. It it what leads to neurological femaleness, and not just femininity.
Femininity vs. Womanhood
There's a difference between being feminine and identifying as a trans woman. One is purely cultural, and the other is a complex combination of neurology, psychology, and culture. Compare someone like James Charles or David Bowie to the many tomboys and butch women of the world. Yes, trans women don't have to be highly feminine to be truly trans. If cis women can like cars, video games, or even suits, why can't a trans woman? To argue otherwise is to appeal to generalizations and stereotypes.
While Chris might not have many classically feminine traits, she does have many classically womanly traits, and common traits among trans woman.
Chris's childhood
Chris's attraction to women, and how it differs from that of a straight man
The curse of genetics: Things Chris can't help
Passing isn't all about hormones and surgery – for many, you have to win the genetic lottery to begin with. Bone structure can't be changed, with a few exceptions like the bones of the face. Even then, surgery is expensive. There is no surgery to remove height (minus cutting off the legs) or narrow the shoulders. While HRT can prevent hair loss, it generally can't reverse it. Even Rogaine isn't perfect, and most wigs within Chris's budget will look obviously synthetic.
For every Blaire White or Samantha Lux gaining notoriety for being a passing trans woman, you have Christine, cursed with a barrel chest and receding hairline. None of that is a reflection on Chris's status as a trans woman, though. It's no fault of her own, either.
Voice
Chris does have an advantage in the voice department; her voice has always been naturally high and bright. Instead of using falsetto, she could be the perfect candidate for voice training. Voice training focuses on using less "weight" when speaking, replacing the nasal tone with something softer while still keeping the pitch and brightness. Many trans women are unaware of this, though, and focus exclusively on pitch. Voice training is notoriously difficult, and I don't blame Chris for not being able to go through with it. Chris also came out before TransVoiceLessons (the gold standard of voice training) rose to prominence. TVL's pre-training voice was actually lower and more masculine than Chris's pre-transition voice, but her new voice is more feminine than even Cyndi Lauper! Chris's tone-deafness might be the main obstacle here.
Chris's voice is also less monotone and more sing-song, as is the case with most autistic women.