User talk:Anaxis/The Case Against the Suitress Policy

This summarises the situation pretty well, but I'd like to add that even after The Suitress Policy was made, Fiona publically went and said her real name on Reddit. That's probably the biggest reason I dislike the policy, she actively does not seem to want protection and is fine with her real name being publicised Cereally (talk) 22:04, 11 September 2023 (EDT)

Double Standards

Yeah, I strongly disagree with the Suitress policy and the weird double standards it shows. If Megan's real name—someone who never could have known what she was getting into, and has wanted absolutely nothing to do with Chris as soon as he started showing his true colours—is out there, then why should Fiona's name get censored? She's shown repeatedly that she doesn't even seem to care whether her name is publicized...

Long Overdue Apology

After reading this in full, I have to admit...I'm actually glad it was decided to cancel this policy, being the one that decided on it in the first place. This entire thing was one of many of the bad decisions that I had made during the whole ILJ drama. Not only did I not ask for user input on this, but it was ultimately a careless, knee-jerk reaction to try and lessen the amount of drama that was being created around every party involved, since several people were utterly adamant on protecting Fiona.

Ironically, it only made things worse, since it coincidentally happened around the same time the Bella ban was being implemented on the Discord server, drawing more attention, and it started getting ridiculous with EVERYTHING regarding her being censored, even Jail Letters.

Long story short, this was a really bad policy that just over-complicated shit, and I don't intend to do anything like this again. Psycho (talk) 23:21, 6 February 2025 (EST)