Difference between revisions of "Sonichu 0 HD"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Accounting for that Chris has replaced Sonichu 15 with its original outright.) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{quote| Well, that's pretty much what I expected.|''Rosechu's Story'' creator Trickie, upon discovering that Chris ripped off her comic.<ref>https://kiwifarms.net/threads/sonichu-15-page-1-dates.37088/page-4#post-2826274</ref>}} | {{quote| Well, that's pretty much what I expected.|''Rosechu's Story'' creator Trickie, upon discovering that Chris ripped off her comic.<ref>https://kiwifarms.net/threads/sonichu-15-page-1-dates.37088/page-4#post-2826274</ref>}} | ||
| Line 7: | Line 5: | ||
| cover = Sonichu15cover2019-min.png | | cover = Sonichu15cover2019-min.png | ||
| coverdate = 16 [[October 2017]] | | coverdate = 16 [[October 2017]] | ||
| finishedcomic = '' | | finishedcomic = ''Superseded'' 17 [[December 2019]] | ||
| pagecount = 60 | | pagecount = 60 | ||
| episodes = 1 | | episodes = 1 | ||
| previous = [[Sonichu 14|''Sonichu'' #14]] | | previous = [[Sonichu 14|''Sonichu'' #14]] | ||
| next = [[Sonichu 16|''Sonichu'' #16]] | | next = [[Sonichu 16|''Sonichu'' #16]] | ||
}} | }} | ||
'''''Sonichu'' #15''' | '''''Sonichu'' #15''' was the seventeenth issue of ''Sonichu''. It was announced by Chris on 17 October 2017, directly after he completed [[Sonichu 12|''Sonichu'' #12]]. It was intended as a "Retelling of the Classic First Three Episodes, BUT with More Details; More Commentary and Dialogue from Sonichu and Rosechu".<ref>https://sonichu.com/cwcki/October_2017_Patreon_posts#Sonichu_.2315_Cover.21</ref>, but the bulk of its content was either [[Things Chris has ripped off|plagiarised]] from ''[http://rosechustory.tumblr.com/ Rosechu's Story]'', a [[Tumblr]] fan comic, or else devised by the [[Idea Guys]]. Its cover is an alternate version of the infamous "Zap to the extreme!" cover on [[Sonichu 0|''Sonichu'' #0]], with a [[Tomgirl|transgender]] Chris directing Sonichu, who responds, "Yes, I will!! Thank you, mother!!!"; Chris believes that his art has improved in the thirteen years between the two books.<ref>https://sonichu.com/cwcki/October_2017_tweets#Sonichu_0_and_15_cover_comparison</ref> Work on the comic, after months of hiatus in mid-2019, came to an end on 17 December 2019 when Chris listed ''Rosechu's Story'' as [[TRUE and HONEST]] Sonichu canon at [[Chris and business|CWCVille Shopping]], selling it beside ''Sonichu'' 0 through 13 and making ''Sonichu'' 15 the second instalment in the series (after ''Sonichu'' 16) to be abandoned while incomplete. | ||
[[File:Sonichu's parents gassed to death.png|thumb|left|Sonichu mourning his parents' death.]] | |||
For the most part, Chris adapted ''Rosechu's Story'' faithfully, occasionally [[Chris and writing|revise dialogue]] to his taste. His most noteworthy change to the plot was in deciding to depict the Raichu with a blunt tail (in the ''Pokémon'' games, this marks a Raichu as female), even though ''Rosechu's Story'''s plot depended on [[Rosechu]] having been born male, in an obvious attempt to put his foot down on the much-debated and -ridiculed topic of Rosechu's birth gender. However, the [[Idea Guys]] convinced Chris that he was wrong and that Rosechu was really born male,<ref>[[December 2017 Facebook posts#Is Rosechu a transwoman?]]</ref> so Chris reversed his alteration in a 2019 revision. They also persuaded him that Sonichu's parents had been gassed to death by Team Rocket's coughing Pokémon. | |||
==Comic pages== | ==Comic pages== | ||
| Line 141: | Line 78: | ||
==Revisions== | ==Revisions== | ||
<center> | <center> | ||
{| class="wikitable collapsible" width="600" | {| class="wikitable collapsible" width="600" | ||
| Line 154: | Line 90: | ||
|[[File:Sonichu 15 cover.jpg|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]] | |[[File:Sonichu 15 cover.jpg|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]] | ||
|[[File:Sonichu15cover2019-min.png|120px|center]] | |[[File:Sonichu15cover2019-min.png|120px|center]] | ||
| | |The original cover did not credit Trickie or ''Rosechu's Story''.<br>For the 2019 revision, Chris scribbled a note in the corner reading: "Also complimenting of Trickie's book, "Rosechu's Story", with permission to quote that book for this one." | ||
|- | |- | ||
|1 | |1 | ||
|[[File:SchuComic15Page1 draft.png|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]] | |[[File:SchuComic15Page1 draft.png|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]] | ||
|[[File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p1.jpg|120px|center]] | |[[File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p1.jpg|120px|center]] | ||
| | |[[Rosechu]]'s tail as a Raichu is blunt in the 2017 original to show she is a natural female; her tail as a Pikachu is heart-shaped for the same reason. (This itself [[continuity|retconned]] [[Sonichu 0]], which depicted the Raichu with a pointed tail because Nintendo did not draw male and female Raichus differently in [[2000]].) Chris's 2019, he followed Idea Guy's canon and revised the page to depict the Pikachu/Raichu with pointed tails (by drawing the tails on a separate page, cutting them out and gluing them over the original versions). | ||
|- | |- | ||
|9 | |9 | ||
|[[File:SchuComic15Page9_draft.jpg|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]] | |[[File:SchuComic15Page9_draft.jpg|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]] | ||
|[[File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p9.jpg|120px|center]] | |[[File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p9.jpg|120px|center]] | ||
|Minor date change. The 2017 version gives 14 February 2003, as the date Rosechu and Sonichu meet; the 2019 version is revised to 7 February | |Minor date change. The 2017 version gives 14 February 2003, as the date Rosechu and Sonichu meet; the 2019 version is revised to 7 February. Chris wrote the seven on a slip of paper and glued it over the previous date. | ||
|} | |||
</center> | |||
<center> | |||
{| class="wikitable collapsible" width="600" | |||
|- | |||
!Dialogue in ''Rosechu's Story'' | |||
!Revised in ''Sonichu'' 15 | |||
|- | |||
|"Yeah, right" | |||
|"Ch-yeah, right" | |||
|- | |||
|"another Pokemon like me just showing up at the door?" | |||
|"another Pokemon for my rose just showing up at the door?" | |||
|- | |||
|"Woah" | |||
|"Woahly" | |||
|- | |||
|"For the love of -" | |||
|"For the love of Arceus!" | |||
|- | |||
|"Seriously, Kel?? You never once noticed my tail is pointed?!" | |||
|"Seriously, Kel?? You never once noticed my tail is pointed?! Much less, my [[Pickle|wee-wee]]?" | |||
|- | |||
|"You sure put the little one through the wringer!" | |||
|"You sure put the little on [sic] through the wringer! Her X-rays showed no fractured or broken bones at all." | |||
|} | |} | ||
</center> | </center> | ||
==Gallery== | ==Gallery== | ||
<center><gallery> | <center><gallery> | ||
CWC's Sonichu 15 vs Trickie's Rosechu's Story fancomic.png|Comparing art between ''Sonichu'' #15 and fan comic ''Rosechu's Story''. | |||
CWC's Sonichu 15 vs Trickie's Rosechu's Story fancomic 2.png|An entire page is taken from ''Rosechu's Story'', down to the dialogue. | |||
Chris pen grip 2019.jpg|Chris copying Rosechu's Story. Note the awkward pen grip + gym gloves hampering his drawing ability. | |||
File:Trickiechu.jpg|"Trickiechu", a [[TSSSF]] card made by Chris, on the creator of ''Rosechu's Story''. | File:Trickiechu.jpg|"Trickiechu", a [[TSSSF]] card made by Chris, on the creator of ''Rosechu's Story''. | ||
</gallery></center> | </gallery></center> | ||
Revision as of 19:55, 9 April 2020
| “ | Well, that's pretty much what I expected. | ” |
| Rosechu's Story creator Trickie, upon discovering that Chris ripped off her comic.[1] | ||
| Sonichu #15 | |
|---|---|
| |
| Cover Date: | 16 October 2017 |
| Finished: | Superseded 17 December 2019 |
| Page Count: | 60 |
| Episodes: | 1 |
| Sonichu Comics | |
| Previous Sonichu #14 |
Next Sonichu #16 |
Sonichu #15 was the seventeenth issue of Sonichu. It was announced by Chris on 17 October 2017, directly after he completed Sonichu #12. It was intended as a "Retelling of the Classic First Three Episodes, BUT with More Details; More Commentary and Dialogue from Sonichu and Rosechu".[2], but the bulk of its content was either plagiarised from Rosechu's Story, a Tumblr fan comic, or else devised by the Idea Guys. Its cover is an alternate version of the infamous "Zap to the extreme!" cover on Sonichu #0, with a transgender Chris directing Sonichu, who responds, "Yes, I will!! Thank you, mother!!!"; Chris believes that his art has improved in the thirteen years between the two books.[3] Work on the comic, after months of hiatus in mid-2019, came to an end on 17 December 2019 when Chris listed Rosechu's Story as TRUE and HONEST Sonichu canon at CWCVille Shopping, selling it beside Sonichu 0 through 13 and making Sonichu 15 the second instalment in the series (after Sonichu 16) to be abandoned while incomplete.
For the most part, Chris adapted Rosechu's Story faithfully, occasionally revise dialogue to his taste. His most noteworthy change to the plot was in deciding to depict the Raichu with a blunt tail (in the Pokémon games, this marks a Raichu as female), even though Rosechu's Story's plot depended on Rosechu having been born male, in an obvious attempt to put his foot down on the much-debated and -ridiculed topic of Rosechu's birth gender. However, the Idea Guys convinced Chris that he was wrong and that Rosechu was really born male,[4] so Chris reversed his alteration in a 2019 revision. They also persuaded him that Sonichu's parents had been gassed to death by Team Rocket's coughing Pokémon.
Comic pages
| Pages from Sonichu 15 |
|---|
.jpg)
Revisions
| Sonichu #15 Version Comparison | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Page Number | 2017 Version | 2019 Version | Notes |
| Cover |  |
|
The original cover did not credit Trickie or Rosechu's Story. For the 2019 revision, Chris scribbled a note in the corner reading: "Also complimenting of Trickie's book, "Rosechu's Story", with permission to quote that book for this one." |
| 1 |  |
 |
Rosechu's tail as a Raichu is blunt in the 2017 original to show she is a natural female; her tail as a Pikachu is heart-shaped for the same reason. (This itself retconned Sonichu 0, which depicted the Raichu with a pointed tail because Nintendo did not draw male and female Raichus differently in 2000.) Chris's 2019, he followed Idea Guy's canon and revised the page to depict the Pikachu/Raichu with pointed tails (by drawing the tails on a separate page, cutting them out and gluing them over the original versions). |
| 9 |  |
 |
Minor date change. The 2017 version gives 14 February 2003, as the date Rosechu and Sonichu meet; the 2019 version is revised to 7 February. Chris wrote the seven on a slip of paper and glued it over the previous date. |
| Dialogue in Rosechu's Story | Revised in Sonichu 15 |
|---|---|
| "Yeah, right" | "Ch-yeah, right" |
| "another Pokemon like me just showing up at the door?" | "another Pokemon for my rose just showing up at the door?" |
| "Woah" | "Woahly" |
| "For the love of -" | "For the love of Arceus!" |
| "Seriously, Kel?? You never once noticed my tail is pointed?!" | "Seriously, Kel?? You never once noticed my tail is pointed?! Much less, my wee-wee?" |
| "You sure put the little one through the wringer!" | "You sure put the little on [sic] through the wringer! Her X-rays showed no fractured or broken bones at all." |
Gallery
Comparing art between Sonichu #15 and fan comic Rosechu's Story.
An entire page is taken from Rosechu's Story, down to the dialogue.
Chris copying Rosechu's Story. Note the awkward pen grip + gym gloves hampering his drawing ability.
"Trickiechu", a TSSSF card made by Chris, on the creator of Rosechu's Story.
Sources