Difference between revisions of "Sonichu 0 HD"

From CWCki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(split intro into production notes and plot sections)
 
(41 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Draft}}
{{Draft}}


{{quote| Well, that's pretty much what I expected.|''Rosechu's Story'' creator Trickie, upon discovering that Chris ripped off her comic.<ref>https://kiwifarms.net/threads/sonichu-15-page-1-dates.37088/page-4#post-2826274</ref>}}
{{quote| Well, that's pretty much what I expected.|''Rosechu's Story'' creator Trickie, upon discovering that Chris ripped off her comic.<ref>[[Kiwi Farms posts (other users)#Trickie Comments on Sonichu 15]]</ref>}}


{{Infobox/Comic
{{Infobox/Comic
| titleandissue  = Sonichu #15
| titleandissue  = Sonichu #0 HD
| cover          = Sonichu15cover2019-min.png
| cover          = Sonichu book 0 hd cover by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o1j5-pre.jpg
| coverdate      = 16 [[October 2017]]
| coverdate      = 16 [[October 2017]]
| finishedcomic  =  
| finishedcomic  =  
Line 14: Line 14:
}}
}}


'''''Sonichu'' #15''' is the seventeenth issue of ''Sonichu''. It is a mix of material [[Things Chris has ripped off|plagiarised]] from a fan comic titled ''[http://rosechustory.tumblr.com/ Rosechu's Story]'', and lore [[brainwashed]] into Chris by the [[Idea Guys]]. Its cover is an alternate version of the infamous "Zap to the extreme!" cover on [[Sonichu 0|''Sonichu'' #0]], with a [[transgender]] Chris directing Sonichu, who responds, "Yes, I will!! Thank you, mother!!!"; Chris believes that his art has improved in the thirteen years between the two books.<ref>https://sonichu.com/cwcki/October_2017_tweets#Sonichu_0_and_15_cover_comparison</ref>
'''''Sonichu'' #0 HD''', previously known as '''''Sonichu'' #15''', is the seventeenth issue of ''Sonichu''. It is a mix of material [[Things Chris has ripped off|plagiarised]] from a fan comic titled ''[http://rosechustory.tumblr.com/ Rosechu's Story]'' and lore [[brainwashed]] into Chris by the [[Idea Guys]]. Its cover is an alternate version of the infamous "Zap to the extreme!" cover on [[Sonichu 0|''Sonichu'' #0]], with a [[transgender]] Chris directing Sonichu, who responds, "Yes, I will!! Thank you, mother!!!"; Chris believes that his art has improved in the thirteen years between the two books.<ref>[[October_2017_tweets#Sonichu_0_and_15_cover_comparison]]</ref>
 
Due to Chris's [[Jail Saga|2021 legal troubles]], it initially seemed that the issue would not be completed anytime soon. His [[2023]] return to DeviantArt and renumbering of the comic, however, indicated he was resuming work. He posted two uncolored pages in [[2024]].


==Production notes==
==Production notes==
''Sonichu 15'' was announced by Chris on 17 October 2017 directly after he completed [[Sonichu 12|''Sonichu'' #12]], put on hold during the [[Idea Guys]] saga, and resumed in July 2019 until Chris lost interest and abandoned the comic again.
''Sonichu 15'' was announced by Chris on 17 October 2017 directly after he completed [[Sonichu 12|''Sonichu'' #12]], put on hold during the [[Idea Guys]] saga, and resumed in July 2019 until Chris lost interest and abandoned the comic again. He sporadically resumed it in [[2023]] - by the following year, he took five months to draw three pages.<ref name=april2023>[[April 2024 social media posts#Still Doing the Comics]]</ref><ref name=sept2024>[[September 2024 social media posts#Book #0 HD progress and CWCki correction]]</ref>


At first, it was intended as a "Retelling of the Classic First Three Episodes, BUT with More Details; More Commentary and Dialogue from Sonichu and Rosechu",<ref>https://sonichu.com/cwcki/October_2017_Patreon_posts#Sonichu_.2315_Cover.21</ref> However, in [[October 2017]], Chris learned of the fan comic ''Rosechu's Story''.<ref>[[October 2017 tweets#Chris finds out about Rosechu's Story, is confused by the title]]</ref> Reading it on [[Tumblr]], he enjoyed its story so much he decided to copy it for ''Sonichu 15'', acknowledging the source material with a hastily scribbled note on the front cover.
It was intended as a "Retelling of the Classic First Three Episodes, BUT with More Details; More Commentary and Dialogue from Sonichu and Rosechu",<ref>[[October_2017_Patreon_posts#Sonichu #15 Cover!]]</ref> Days before the announcement, Chris learned of the fan comic ''Rosechu's Story''.<ref>[[October 2017 tweets#Chris finds out about Rosechu's Story, is confused by the title]]</ref> Reading it on [[Tumblr]], he enjoyed its story so much he decided to copy it for ''Sonichu 15'', acknowledging the source material with a hastily scribbled note on the front cover.


{{quote|Well, Christine has already indicated to me that she considers this to be part of the chronicled history of the electric hedgehogs, and that all this stuff was in her brain somewhere, it just didn't come out until she read it in my comic. So even if I did make a fuss about it, she probably would've done this anyway and the only difference would be that I wouldn't get credit for it at all.|''Rosechu's Story'' creator Trickie.<ref>https://kiwifarms.net/threads/sonichu-15.58084/post-4951373</ref>}}
{{quote|Well, Christine has already indicated to me that she considers [Rosechu's Story] to be part of the chronicled history of the electric hedgehogs, and that all this stuff was in her brain somewhere, it just didn't come out until she read it in my comic. So even if I did make a fuss about it, she probably would've done this anyway and the only difference would be that I wouldn't get credit for it at all.|''Rosechu's Story'' creator Trickie.<ref>[[Kiwi Farms posts (other users)#Trickie's Handling of Chris's Copying of Rosechu's Story]]</ref>}}


[[File:Rosechu's Story front back cover.jpeg|thumb|200px|Misleading advertising. A cover Chris drew for Rosechu's Story, with only fine print on the back cover vaguely crediting the actual author and illustrator.]]
Chris has shown some disrespect towards Trickie. When ripping off one of her pages, which had Rosechu mention a visit to Professor [[Cole]] (a nod to Chris's [[CWCipedia]] entry which listed a "Professor Cole"), Chris changed the dialogue for ''Sonichu'' #0 HD to have Rosechu say "Professor Pine" instead. He then tweeted about the change and wrote, "Sorry, Tricky, but now you know. ⚡️💙⚡️"<ref name=sept2024></ref> However, five years previously, Chris had still accepted Cole as the professor, but still felt the need to claim that Cole was later demoted from his position.<ref>[[April 2019 social media posts#CWCVille's Pokemon Professor]]</ref>


In addition to ripping off ''Rosechu's Story'', Chris also decided to monetize it for himself. In June 2019, Chris downloaded ''Rosechu's Story'', drew a cover for it in his own artstyle, had it printed as a book through [[Lulu]], and placed it into a lot of Sonichu comics for sale on [[Ebay]]<ref>[[2019 Sales Listings#Sonichu Graphic Novel Set From Zero To Awakening]]</ref> and also sold copies through [[Cwcvilleshopping.com]].
[[File:Rosechu's Story front back cover.jpeg|thumb|200px|Misleading advertising. A cover Chris drew for ''Rosechu's Story'', with only the spine and fine print on the back cover crediting the actual author and illustrator.]]
 
In addition to ripping off ''Rosechu's Story'', Chris also decided to monetize it for himself. In June 2019, Chris downloaded ''Rosechu's Story'', drew a cover for it in his own artstyle, had it printed as a book through [[Lulu]], and placed it into a lot of Sonichu comics for sale on [[eBay]]<ref>[[2019 Sales Listings#Sonichu Graphic Novel Set From Zero To Awakening]]</ref> and also sold copies through [[Cwcvilleshopping.com]].
 
In [[August 2023]], Chris uploaded a batch of artwork to his [[NightStarRosechu2891]] DeviantART account. Among those were previously-unreleased colorized versions, and one unreleased page, of the comic. A revised version of the cover was also among the batch; in the newest cover, Chris had altered the comic number, by gluing a slip of paper on top of the page, changing the previous #15 to #0 HD.
 
On 15 [[April 2024]], Chris posted an uncoloured page 65 from the comic to [[Twitter]], signed "Jesus Christine W. Chandler Sonichu Prime", as proof that he was still working on new ''Sonichu''.<ref name=april2023></ref>
 
On [[September 2024]], he posted an uncolored page 67.<ref name=sept2024></ref>


==Plot==
==Plot==
Line 32: Line 42:
Chris's weaknesses at [[writing]] stories stands in contrast to the fan favorite ''Rosechu's Story''. Despite extensively copying its scenes, Chris still managed to water down the comic's storyline and emotional impact by ignoring scenes of character conflict, inserting walls of text, revising dialogue to his taste, and breaking up the story flow by adding pages detailing an irrelevant portion of Sonichu's day.
Chris's weaknesses at [[writing]] stories stands in contrast to the fan favorite ''Rosechu's Story''. Despite extensively copying its scenes, Chris still managed to water down the comic's storyline and emotional impact by ignoring scenes of character conflict, inserting walls of text, revising dialogue to his taste, and breaking up the story flow by adding pages detailing an irrelevant portion of Sonichu's day.
[[File:Sonichu 15 revision tail.png|thumb|Left, original tail. Right, Chris physically altered the page to conform with lore from the [[Idea Guys]].]]
[[File:Sonichu 15 revision tail.png|thumb|Left, original tail. Right, Chris physically altered the page to conform with lore from the [[Idea Guys]].]]
His most noteworthy change to the plot was in deciding to depict the Raichu with a blunt tail (in the ''Pokémon'' games, this marks a Raichu as female), even though ''Rosechu's Story'''s plot depended on [[Rosechu]] having been born male, in an obvious attempt to put his foot down on the much-debated and -ridiculed topic of Rosechu's birth gender. However, the [[Idea Guys]] subsequently [[brainwashed]] Chris into believing that he was wrong and that Rosechu was really born male,<ref>[[December 2017 Facebook posts#Is Rosechu a transwoman?]]</ref> so Chris reversed his alteration in a 2019 revision.
His most noteworthy change to the plot was in deciding to depict the Raichu with a blunt tail (in the ''Pokémon'' games, this marks a Raichu as female), even though ''Rosechu's Story'''s plot depended on [[Rosechu]] having been born male, in an obvious attempt to put his foot down on the much-debated-and-ridiculed topic of Rosechu's birth gender. However, the [[Idea Guys]] subsequently [[brainwashed]] Chris into believing that he was wrong and that Rosechu was really born male,<ref>[[December 2017 Facebook posts#Is Rosechu a transwoman?]]</ref> so Chris reversed his alteration in a 2019 revision.


Partway through ''Sonichu 15'', at page 33, Chris runs out of material to adapt from ''Rosechu's Story'' and begins to tell Sonichu's backstory, featuring lore the [[Idea Guys]] had brainwashed into him during one of the comic's hiatuses, one example being Sonichu's parents had been gassed to death by Team Rocket's Koffing Pokémon.
Partway through ''Sonichu 15'', at page 33, Chris ran out of material to adapt from ''Rosechu's Story'' and begins to tell Sonichu's backstory, featuring lore the [[Idea Guys]] had brainwashed into him during one of the comic's hiatuses, one example being Sonichu's parents had been gassed to death by Team Rocket's Koffing Pokémon. Art-wise, as soon as he shifted from copying Trickie's scenes, the composition instantly reverted back to Chris's typical style of characters with minimal backgrounds surrounded by text.


==Comic pages==
==Comic pages==
Line 40: Line 50:
<center>{{collapsible
<center>{{collapsible
|Pages from Sonichu 15
|Pages from Sonichu 15
|<gallery>
|<gallery mode="nolines" perrow="10">
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p1.jpg
File:Sonichu15cover2019-min.png | Cover (2019)
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p2.jpg
</gallery>
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p3.jpg
<gallery caption="The Genesis of Sonichu & Rosechu" mode="nolines" perrow="10">
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p4.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p1.jpg | Page 1 (2019)
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p5.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p2.jpg | Page 2
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p6.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p3.jpg | Page 3
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p7.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p4.jpg | Page 4
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p8.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p5.jpg | Page 5
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p9.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p6.jpg | Page 6
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p10.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p7.jpg | Page 7
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p11.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p8.jpg | Page 8
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p12.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p9.jpg | Page 9 (2019)
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p13.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p10.png | Page 10
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p14.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p11.png | Page 11
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p15.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p12.png | Page 12
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p16.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p13.png | Page 13
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p17.png
File:Sonichu book 0 hd page 14 by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o2cw-pre.jpg ‎| Page 14
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p18.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p15.png | Page 15
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p19.jpg
File:Sonichu book 0 hd page 16 by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o2hd-pre.jpg ‎| Page 16
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p20.png
File:Sonichu book 0 hd page 17 by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o2kg-pre.jpg ‎| Page 17
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p21.png
File:Sonichu book 0 hd page 18 by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o2mr-pre.jpg ‎| Page 18
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p22-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p19.jpg | Page 19
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p23-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p20.png | Page 20
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p24-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p21.png | Page 21
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p25.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p22-min.png | Page 22
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p26.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p23-min.png | Page 23
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p27.png
File:Sonichu book 0 hd page 24 by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o2r9-pre.jpg ‎| Page 24
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p28.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p25.png | Page 25
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p29-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p26.png | Page 26
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p30-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p27.png | Page 27
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p31-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p28.png | Page 28
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p32.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p29-min.png | Page 29
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p33-min.png
File:Leaked page 2.jpg | Page 30
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p34-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p31-min.png | Page 31
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p35-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p32.jpg | Page 32
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p36.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p33-min.png | Page 33
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p37-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p34-min.png | Page 34
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p38-min.png
File:Sonichu book 0 hd page 35 by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o2uo-pre.jpg ‎| Page 35
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p39.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p36.jpg | Page 36
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p40.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p37-min.png | Page 37
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p41.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p38-min.png | Page 38
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p42-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p39.jpg | Page 39
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p43-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p40.jpg | Page 40
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p44-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p41.jpg | Page 41
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p45.jpg
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p42-min.png | Page 42
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p46.jpg
File:Leaked page 1.jpg | Page 43
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p47-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p44-min.png | Page 44
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p48-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p45.jpg | Page 45
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p49-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p46.jpg | Page 46
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p50-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p47-min.png | Page 47
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p64-min.png
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p48-min.png | Page 48
 
File:Sonichu book 0 hd page 49 by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o2x8-pre.jpg ‎| Page 49
</gallery>}}</center>
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p50-min.png | Page 50
File:Sonichu book0 hd page 52 by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o30d-pre.jpg ‎| Page 52
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p64-min.png | Page 64
File:Sonichu15-2024draft-p65.jpg| Page 65
File:X - Book 0 HD page 67 uncolored.jpeg| Page 67
File:Book 0 HD uncolored page 6 October 2024.jpeg| Page 71
</gallery>
<gallery caption="Original Uncolored Pages" mode="nolines" perrow="10">
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p14.png | Page 14
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p16.png | Page 16
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p17.png | Page 17
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p18.jpg | Page 18
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p24-min.png | Page 24
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p30-min.png | Page 30
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p35-min.png | Page 35
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p43-min.png | Page 43
File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p49-min.png | Page 49
</gallery>
<gallery caption="Original 2017 Pages" mode="nolines" perrow="10">
File:Sonichu - Issue 15, Cover.jpg | Cover (2017)
File:SchuComic15Page1 draft.png | Page 1 (2017)
File:SchuComic15Page9 draft.jpg | Page 9 (2017)
</gallery>
}}</center>


==Revisions==
==Revisions==
Line 103: Line 136:
!2017 Version
!2017 Version
!2019 Version
!2019 Version
!2023 Version
!Notes
!Notes
|-
|-
|Cover
|Cover
|[[File:Sonichu 15 cover.jpg|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]]
|[[File:Sonichu - Issue 15, Cover.jpg|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]]
|[[File:Sonichu15cover2019-min.png|120px|center]]
|[[File:Sonichu15cover2019-min.png|120px|center]]
|The original cover did not credit Trickie or ''Rosechu's Story''.<br>For the 2019 revision, Chris scribbled a note in the corner reading: "Also complimenting of Trickie's book, "Rosechu's Story", with permission to quote that book for this one."
|[[File:Sonichu book 0 hd cover by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o1j5-pre.jpg|120px|center]]
|The original cover did not credit Trickie or ''Rosechu's Story''.<br>For the 2019 revision, Chris scribbled a note in the corner reading: "Also complimenting of Trickie's book, "Rosechu's Story", with permission to quote that book for this one." In 2023, the comic number was altered to "0 HD".
|-
|-
|1
|1
|[[File:SchuComic15Page1 draft.png|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]]
|[[File:SchuComic15Page1 draft.png|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]]
|[[File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p1.jpg|120px|center]]
|[[File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p1.jpg|120px|center]]
|
|[[Rosechu]]'s tail as a Raichu is blunt in the 2017 original to show she is a natural female; her tail as a Pikachu is heart-shaped for the same reason. (This itself [[continuity|retconned]] [[Sonichu 0]], which depicted the Raichu with a pointed tail because Nintendo did not draw male and female Raichus differently in [[2000]].) In Chris's 2019 revision, he followed Idea Guy's canon and revised the page to depict the Pikachu/Raichu with pointed tails (by drawing the tails on a separate page, cutting them out and gluing them over the original versions).
|[[Rosechu]]'s tail as a Raichu is blunt in the 2017 original to show she is a natural female; her tail as a Pikachu is heart-shaped for the same reason. (This itself [[continuity|retconned]] [[Sonichu 0]], which depicted the Raichu with a pointed tail because Nintendo did not draw male and female Raichus differently in [[2000]].) In Chris's 2019 revision, he followed Idea Guy's canon and revised the page to depict the Pikachu/Raichu with pointed tails (by drawing the tails on a separate page, cutting them out and gluing them over the original versions).
|-
|-
Line 118: Line 154:
|[[File:SchuComic15Page9_draft.jpg|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]]
|[[File:SchuComic15Page9_draft.jpg|120px|frameless|center|text-bottom]]
|[[File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p9.jpg|120px|center]]
|[[File:Sonichu15-2019draft-p9.jpg|120px|center]]
|
|Minor date change. The 2017 version gives 14 February 2003, as the date Rosechu and Sonichu meet; the 2019 version is revised to 7 February. Chris wrote the seven on a slip of paper and glued it over the previous date.
|Minor date change. The 2017 version gives 14 February 2003, as the date Rosechu and Sonichu meet; the 2019 version is revised to 7 February. Chris wrote the seven on a slip of paper and glued it over the previous date.
|}
|}
Line 146: Line 183:
|}
|}
</center>
</center>
==Gallery==
==Gallery==
<center><gallery>
<center><gallery>
Line 156: Line 194:
==Sources==
==Sources==
<references/>
<references/>
 
{{articleofthenow}}
{{Sonichu}}
{{Sonichu}}
[[Category:Concepts influenced by Idea Guy]]
[[Category:Concepts influenced by Idea Guy]]
[[Category:Sonichu comic book issues]]
[[Category:Sonichu comic book issues]]

Latest revision as of 09:22, 28 October 2024

Chris pen grip 2019.jpg
Draft

This comic is currently in-progress and/or online in draft form only. Pages may be uncolored or missing.
Well, that's pretty much what I expected.
Rosechu's Story creator Trickie, upon discovering that Chris ripped off her comic.[1]
Sonichu #0 HD
Sonichu book 0 hd cover by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o1j5-pre.jpg
Cover Date: 16 October 2017
Page Count: 60 (so far)
Episodes: 1
Sonichu Comics
Previous
Sonichu #14
Next
Sonichu #16



Sonichu #0 HD, previously known as Sonichu #15, is the seventeenth issue of Sonichu. It is a mix of material plagiarised from a fan comic titled Rosechu's Story and lore brainwashed into Chris by the Idea Guys. Its cover is an alternate version of the infamous "Zap to the extreme!" cover on Sonichu #0, with a transgender Chris directing Sonichu, who responds, "Yes, I will!! Thank you, mother!!!"; Chris believes that his art has improved in the thirteen years between the two books.[2]

Due to Chris's 2021 legal troubles, it initially seemed that the issue would not be completed anytime soon. His 2023 return to DeviantArt and renumbering of the comic, however, indicated he was resuming work. He posted two uncolored pages in 2024.

Production notes

Sonichu 15 was announced by Chris on 17 October 2017 directly after he completed Sonichu #12, put on hold during the Idea Guys saga, and resumed in July 2019 until Chris lost interest and abandoned the comic again. He sporadically resumed it in 2023 - by the following year, he took five months to draw three pages.[3][4]

It was intended as a "Retelling of the Classic First Three Episodes, BUT with More Details; More Commentary and Dialogue from Sonichu and Rosechu",[5] Days before the announcement, Chris learned of the fan comic Rosechu's Story.[6] Reading it on Tumblr, he enjoyed its story so much he decided to copy it for Sonichu 15, acknowledging the source material with a hastily scribbled note on the front cover.

Well, Christine has already indicated to me that she considers [Rosechu's Story] to be part of the chronicled history of the electric hedgehogs, and that all this stuff was in her brain somewhere, it just didn't come out until she read it in my comic. So even if I did make a fuss about it, she probably would've done this anyway and the only difference would be that I wouldn't get credit for it at all.
Rosechu's Story creator Trickie.[7]

Chris has shown some disrespect towards Trickie. When ripping off one of her pages, which had Rosechu mention a visit to Professor Cole (a nod to Chris's CWCipedia entry which listed a "Professor Cole"), Chris changed the dialogue for Sonichu #0 HD to have Rosechu say "Professor Pine" instead. He then tweeted about the change and wrote, "Sorry, Tricky, but now you know. ⚡️💙⚡️"[4] However, five years previously, Chris had still accepted Cole as the professor, but still felt the need to claim that Cole was later demoted from his position.[8]

Misleading advertising. A cover Chris drew for Rosechu's Story, with only the spine and fine print on the back cover crediting the actual author and illustrator.

In addition to ripping off Rosechu's Story, Chris also decided to monetize it for himself. In June 2019, Chris downloaded Rosechu's Story, drew a cover for it in his own artstyle, had it printed as a book through Lulu, and placed it into a lot of Sonichu comics for sale on eBay[9] and also sold copies through Cwcvilleshopping.com.

In August 2023, Chris uploaded a batch of artwork to his NightStarRosechu2891 DeviantART account. Among those were previously-unreleased colorized versions, and one unreleased page, of the comic. A revised version of the cover was also among the batch; in the newest cover, Chris had altered the comic number, by gluing a slip of paper on top of the page, changing the previous #15 to #0 HD.

On 15 April 2024, Chris posted an uncoloured page 65 from the comic to Twitter, signed "Jesus Christine W. Chandler Sonichu Prime", as proof that he was still working on new Sonichu.[3]

On September 2024, he posted an uncolored page 67.[4]

Plot

Sonichu mourning his parents' death, an example of the lore introduced by the Idea Guys.

Chris's weaknesses at writing stories stands in contrast to the fan favorite Rosechu's Story. Despite extensively copying its scenes, Chris still managed to water down the comic's storyline and emotional impact by ignoring scenes of character conflict, inserting walls of text, revising dialogue to his taste, and breaking up the story flow by adding pages detailing an irrelevant portion of Sonichu's day.

Left, original tail. Right, Chris physically altered the page to conform with lore from the Idea Guys.

His most noteworthy change to the plot was in deciding to depict the Raichu with a blunt tail (in the Pokémon games, this marks a Raichu as female), even though Rosechu's Story's plot depended on Rosechu having been born male, in an obvious attempt to put his foot down on the much-debated-and-ridiculed topic of Rosechu's birth gender. However, the Idea Guys subsequently brainwashed Chris into believing that he was wrong and that Rosechu was really born male,[10] so Chris reversed his alteration in a 2019 revision.

Partway through Sonichu 15, at page 33, Chris ran out of material to adapt from Rosechu's Story and begins to tell Sonichu's backstory, featuring lore the Idea Guys had brainwashed into him during one of the comic's hiatuses, one example being Sonichu's parents had been gassed to death by Team Rocket's Koffing Pokémon. Art-wise, as soon as he shifted from copying Trickie's scenes, the composition instantly reverted back to Chris's typical style of characters with minimal backgrounds surrounded by text.

Comic pages

Pages from Sonichu 15

Revisions

Sonichu #15 Version Comparison
Page Number 2017 Version 2019 Version 2023 Version Notes
Cover
Sonichu - Issue 15, Cover.jpg
Sonichu15cover2019-min.png
Sonichu book 0 hd cover by nightstarrosechu2891 dg6o1j5-pre.jpg
The original cover did not credit Trickie or Rosechu's Story.
For the 2019 revision, Chris scribbled a note in the corner reading: "Also complimenting of Trickie's book, "Rosechu's Story", with permission to quote that book for this one." In 2023, the comic number was altered to "0 HD".
1
SchuComic15Page1 draft.png
Sonichu15-2019draft-p1.jpg
Rosechu's tail as a Raichu is blunt in the 2017 original to show she is a natural female; her tail as a Pikachu is heart-shaped for the same reason. (This itself retconned Sonichu 0, which depicted the Raichu with a pointed tail because Nintendo did not draw male and female Raichus differently in 2000.) In Chris's 2019 revision, he followed Idea Guy's canon and revised the page to depict the Pikachu/Raichu with pointed tails (by drawing the tails on a separate page, cutting them out and gluing them over the original versions).
9
SchuComic15Page9 draft.jpg
Sonichu15-2019draft-p9.jpg
Minor date change. The 2017 version gives 14 February 2003, as the date Rosechu and Sonichu meet; the 2019 version is revised to 7 February. Chris wrote the seven on a slip of paper and glued it over the previous date.
Dialogue in Rosechu's Story Revised in Sonichu 15
"Yeah, right" "Ch-yeah, right"
"another Pokemon like me just showing up at the door?" "another Pokemon for my rose just showing up at the door?"
"Woah" "Woahly"
"For the love of -" "For the love of Arceus!"
"Seriously, Kel?? You never once noticed my tail is pointed?!" "Seriously, Kel?? You never once noticed my tail is pointed?! Much less, my wee-wee?"
"You sure put the little one through the wringer!" "You sure put the little on [sic] through the wringer! Her X-rays showed no fractured or broken bones at all."

Gallery

Sources